Metal and zirconia crowns are often used to restore primary teeth in paediatric dentistry, but making the correct material choice is critical to achieve the best patient outcome.
About the Guest Author
Dr Diane Tay is a Sydney-based specialist paediatric dentist with a Doctorate of Clinical Dentistry from The University of Sydney. Her expertise includes managing special needs children, dental trauma, and oral pathology. She works at The Children’s Hospital at Westmead and lectures at The University of Sydney and Charles Sturt University.
Paediatric dentistry is a specialised field focusing on the oral health of children and their unique developmental needs. Although primary teeth are temporary, their role is crucial in guiding the alignment of permanent teeth, supporting speech development, and maintaining chewing efficiency for proper nutrition.
Beyond these functional aspects, the appearance of primary teeth also significantly impacts a child’s confidence and social interactions. A healthy smile enables children to feel self-assured in various settings, whereas decayed or missing teeth can lead to embarrassment and diminished self-esteem.
When primary teeth suffer from extensive decay or damage, restorative solutions may become essential. Crowns are among the most effective treatment options for severely compromised teeth. By providing full coverage, crowns protect the tooth from further decay, restore its functionality, and enhance aesthetics.
In paediatric dentistry, stainless steel crowns and zirconia crowns are widely used for restoring primary teeth. Each material offers unique advantages and considerations, so the choice between stainless steel crowns and zirconia crowns is often dependent on factors such as the child’s clinical needs, the tooth’s location, and family priorities.
Reasons to restore a primary tooth
Restoring primary teeth is essential for maintaining their role in a child’s oral development and overall well being. One of their primary functions is to act as natural space maintainers to ensure that permanent teeth erupt in the correct position by holding space in the dental arch.
Premature loss of a primary tooth can cause neighbouring teeth to drift into the gap, leading to misalignment or crowding, which may necessitate orthodontic intervention later in life.
Chewing is another critical function of primary teeth. Damaged or decayed teeth can impair a child’s ability to chew effectively, affecting digestion and potentially leading to nutritional deficiencies. Children who experience discomfort may avoid harder, nutrient-rich foods such as fruits and vegetables, which are essential for growth and development. Restoring these teeth ensures that children can maintain a healthy, balanced diet.
Speech development is also closely tied to the presence and condition of primary teeth. Missing or decayed teeth, particularly in the anterior region, can cause difficulties in articulating certain sounds, which may delay a child’s language acquisition. Restoring these teeth supports proper speech development so children can communicate clearly and confidently.
Aesthetics also play a significant role in the decision to restore primary teeth. Visible decay or missing teeth can make children self-conscious, which may impact their confidence in social settings. Crowns that mimic the natural appearance of teeth help children feel more comfortable and assured.
Finally, restoration provides relief from pain and sensitivity. Conditions such as enamel hypoplasia or amelogenesis imperfecta often result in significant discomfort. By covering affected teeth with crowns, paediatric dentists alleviate sensitivity and restore function to improve the child’s quality of life.
Addressing these concerns promptly prevents further complications, and sets the foundation for healthy oral habits and long-term wellbeing.
Advantages and disadvantages of metal crowns in paediatric dentistry
Stainless steel crowns have been a cornerstone of restorative care in paediatric dentistry for decades, especially for posterior teeth. Their primary advantage lies in their exceptional durability. Designed to withstand significant chewing forces, stainless steel crowns are particularly effective for molars, which experience the greatest pressure during eating. Once placed, they provide reliable protection for the tooth until the primary tooth naturally exfoliates.
Stainless steel crowns are also cost-effective and offer families an affordable yet highly durable option for restoring decayed or damaged teeth. Their affordability, combined with their effectiveness, makes them a popular choice for cases where function takes precedence over aesthetics.
Another advantage of stainless steel crowns is their ease of placement. The preparation process is straightforward and minimally invasive, which allows the preservation of much of the natural tooth structure. This simplicity reduces chair time, and is particularly beneficial for young or anxious children who may struggle to sit through lengthy procedures.
However, despite these strengths, stainless steel crowns have a few disadvantages. Their metallic appearance makes them less suitable for anterior teeth, where aesthetics are a priority.
Additionally, stainless steel crowns may interfere with medical imaging, such as MRIs. The metallic components can cause artefacts, which may complicate scans for children who require regular neurological or oncological monitoring.
In rare cases, allergies to nickel — a common component of stainless steel — can pose a challenge. paediatric dentists must carefully evaluate these potential issues to ensure the material choice is appropriate for the child’s specific needs.
Advantages and disadvantages of zirconia crowns in paediatric dentistry
Zirconia crowns are a more recent innovation in paediatric dentistry, and are valued for their aesthetic appeal and biocompatibility. Zirconia crowns mimic the natural colour of teeth, which typically makes them the preferred option for restoring anterior teeth or any visible primary teeth.
In addition to aesthetics, zirconia crowns are hypoallergenic, which makes them an excellent choice for children with sensitivities or allergies to metal. Their biocompatibility ensures they are safe for a wide range of patients, including those with special medical considerations.
Zirconia crowns are also highly durable. While not as robust as stainless steel crowns in certain scenarios, such as extreme grinding, they are still effective for most chewing and biting functions. This durability, combined with their aesthetic advantages, makes them a versatile option for both anterior and posterior teeth.
However, zirconia crowns come with some challenges. They are usually more expensive than stainless steel crowns, which may limit their accessibility for some families. Placement is also more technique-sensitive. Unlike stainless steel crowns, zirconia crowns require significant tooth reduction to accommodate their thickness, and precise preparation is essential to ensure a proper fit. This makes them less forgiving in cases of imprecise preparation or difficult placement conditions.
For children with bruxism, zirconia crowns may not be the ideal material choice for posterior teeth due to their risk of wear or fracture. However, with careful selection and preparation, they can still offer a reliable and aesthetically pleasing solution for many patients.
Factors to consider in material choice
Making the right material choice for paediatric crowns requires a careful evaluation of several factors, including aesthetics, functionality, and the child’s unique clinical and behavioural needs.
For anterior teeth, where appearance is a primary concern, zirconia crowns are often preferred due to their natural tooth-like appearance. These crowns blend seamlessly with the child’s existing teeth, which helps to boost confidence and reduce potential social anxiety.
For posterior teeth, durability and cost-effectiveness are often the deciding factors. SSCs excel in these cases as they offer robust protection against chewing forces and require minimal preparation. Their affordability also makes them an accessible option for families prioritising function over aesthetics.
However, a child’s medical history can significantly influence the material choice for paediatric crowns. For children undergoing regular MRIs, zirconia crowns are advantageous as they do not interfere with imaging. Conversely, children with bruxism may benefit more from stainless steel crowns, which are more resistant to the excessive wear caused by grinding.
Behavioural considerations also play a role. Young children or those with significant dental anxiety may struggle to tolerate lengthy procedures. In such cases, stainless steel crowns, which are typically quicker and easier to place, may be the better option.
Parental preferences further shape the decision, with many families balancing aesthetic desires with practical concerns such as cost and durability. Educating parents about the benefits and limitations of both materials ensures they can make informed choices tailored to their child’s needs.
Crown preparation recommendations for paediatric cases
Tooth preparation is a critical step in placing paediatric crowns, with significant differences depending on the material choice.
Stainless steel crowns require minimal preparation that typically involves reducing the tooth structure just enough to allow the crown to seat securely – usually with feather-edge margins. This approach often reduces chair time and minimises discomfort, which may be preferable for young or anxious children.
Zirconia crowns, by contrast, demand more extensive preparation. These crowns are thicker than their stainless steel counterparts, necessitating greater tooth reduction to ensure a proper fit. Precision is critical during this process, as zirconia crowns cannot be adjusted chairside. Margins must be carefully designed, with chamfer margins recommended for stability and accuracy. Any deviations in preparation may result in an ill-fitting crown, which could compromise its functionality and longevity.
Maintaining a dry field is crucial when preparing for zirconia crowns. Moisture can interfere with the bonding process, leading to potential complications during cementation. This additional requirement can prolong the procedure, making it more challenging for children who have difficulty remaining still for extended periods.
paediatric dentists must balance these technical considerations with the child’s behaviour and clinical needs, tailoring their preparation approach to ensure the best possible outcome for each case.
Special cementation protocols
Cementation is a crucial step in ensuring the long-term success of paediatric crowns, with distinct protocols required for stainless steel and zirconia crowns. Stainless steel crowns typically rely on standard luting cements, which provide adequate adhesion and retention. The process is relatively forgiving and tends to allow for minor deviations during placement. Basic moisture control is sufficient, which makes the cementation of stainless steel crowns relatively straightforward and efficient.
Zirconia crowns, on the other hand, may require a more meticulous approach. Achieving a passive fit is essential, as zirconia crowns cannot be adjusted after fabrication. Proper tooth preparation is critical to create the ideal seating for the crown. During cementation, maintaining a completely dry field is vital to avoid contamination from saliva or blood, which could weaken the bond between the crown and the tooth.
Haemostasis plays a key role in the success of zirconia crown cementation. Excessive bleeding can interfere with the adhesive properties of resin-based cements, which are typically used for zirconia due to their strong bonding capabilities.
Longevity of paediatric crowns
The longevity of paediatric crowns is a key consideration for both dentists and parents. Both stainless steel crowns and zirconia crowns are designed to last until the primary teeth naturally exfoliate, typically between the ages of 10 and 12.
Replacement of paediatric crowns is uncommon unless there is trauma, severe grinding, or improper placement. Regular dental check-ups are essential to monitor crown integrity and address any emerging issues early. With proper care, both stainless steel and zirconia crowns can provide reliable and lasting protection for primary teeth until natural exfoliation occurs.
Stainless steel crowns are renowned for their durability. They are particularly effective for molars, which endure significant chewing forces. Their robust design resists fractures and wear, ensuring that the restored tooth remains functional throughout the lifespan of the primary tooth. Stainless steel crowns also rarely require maintenance, which typically makes them a reliable and cost-effective solution for long-term restorations.
Zirconia crowns also offer impressive longevity when placed correctly. Their resistance to wear and fractures makes them suitable for both anterior and posterior teeth. Unlike stainless steel crowns, zirconia crowns provide the added benefit of aesthetics. However, their success depends heavily on precise preparation and cementation. Poor technique during placement can compromise their durability.
The final word
Restoring primary teeth helps to maintain a child’s oral health, functionality, and confidence. Crowns provide a reliable solution for protecting severely damaged or decayed teeth to maintain their role in chewing, speech development, and proper alignment of permanent teeth. Both stainless steel and zirconia crowns are effective, but their suitability depends on the child’s clinical needs, the tooth’s location, and family preferences.
Stainless steel crowns excel in durability, affordability, and ease of placement, making them a practical choice for posterior teeth. However, their metallic appearance and potential to interfere with medical imaging can limit their use for anterior teeth or certain medical conditions.
Zirconia crowns, by contrast, offer superior aesthetics and biocompatibility, making them ideal for visible teeth or children with metal sensitivities. These crowns require more meticulous preparation and cementation, but when done correctly, they provide a durable and visually pleasing restoration.
By carefully evaluating factors such as material choice, preparation requirements, and the child’s behaviour, paediatric dentists can tailor treatments to ensure successful outcomes. With proper care and regular dental visits, both types of crowns offer long-lasting solutions that support healthy smiles.
Want to learn more about metal crown vs zirconia crowns in paediatric dentistry?
Register here to watch on-demand at a time that suits you.
Avant Dental is a full-service dental laboratory. To find out more about working with us, please email [email protected] or phone 1800 287 336.